
....so after a long week of sitting (and burning) under the hot Mexican sun, I have finally made it back to snowy New Jersey. With that in mind, I was able to finish Herland but with the price of Internet being $15 a day, I was not able to blog about it. Lucky for all of you I am back and ready to blog about the book they call Herland....
I last left off with the men learning of how the inhabitants of Herland reproduce and thrive as a "nation". The men are in awe of how everyone is able to coexist. This is probably because there is no competition supplied by men, and since everyone is derived from one common source, it is as if they are one huge family. The men are embarassed of the world they come from, and the women of Herland almost feel pity for the men that they come from such a terrible place. Vandyck tries to explain the act of abortion and the women backlash at him. They stress how inhumane that is and how they would never be able to do that. Sommel says this is no way to build up a strong nation and that giving birth to a child (or girl) is an honor, and that you should take this as an honor.
Terry hates Herland. He sees the society itself as a terrifying, uncomplete place and that men are necessary for a nation to thrive. Herland just does not make sense to him. The three men begin relationships with the three women they met in the onset of the book -- Celis, Alima, Ellador. Terry and Jeff find love in Alima and Celis respectively. These two relationships are not as successful as Ellador and Van's. Van sees that the women want to have a mutual bnd and respect for their partner and he loves Ellador accordingly. Each couple is married; the men and women have differing opinions on what sex is: for intercourse or for reproducing.
...It was interesting to see the varying approaches to marriage and sex the three explorers had. Jeff and Van each see it as their female counterpart see it. They are able to compromise with their partners for the most part. Ellador and Van have a blanced relationship and Celis and Jeff have minor problems. They overcome their issues as Celis eventually is impregnated by Jeff, the first in over 2000 years of Herland. Terry thinks he is the owner of Alima, now that they are married, and he attempts to rape her. This leads to the banishment of the men from Herland... Because he has fathered a child with Celis, Jeff decides to stay behind at Herland. Ellador accompanies Van back home and Terry leaves angrily. At first he threatens the country but he later backs down from his threats. The two men and Ellador leave the paridise of Herland and go back to the bi-sexual real world.
This book left many questions such as,
1. What is the world's reaction to Ellador?
2. What will happen to Jeff at Herland?
a. Will his child with Celis be "normal"?
b. If it is a boy, how will that change Herland?
Thank god there is a sequel With Her in Ourland
I'm sure that will be EVERYBODY's book to read!!
In conclusion i found Herland to be a little bit sexist, in the way Gilman made men to seem to root of all evil and that a society of all women could exist perfectly. In the end though, a man is left at Herland and who knows what will happen with that, so in a way men win... as it should be.
With Her in Ourland takes the persepctive of Van and Ellador living in a "real" society. Yes, Google has a Book tab and here it is for
With Her in ourland... Google does it all.
Bring on the next book.